ARIZONA REPORTER




Harvey Critic - 03/05

THE FIRST GRADER, Grade: B+


"We get old too soon and too late smart." That Dutch proverb appears to apply to the title character in Justin Chadwick's sugar-coated movie "The First Grader," based on a true story and filmed on location in rural Kenya with real 5-year-old Kenyan kids in the cast. While the National Geographic Entertainment film has the look of a Hallmark Hall of Fame TV episode, the scenes of British brutality just might make the pic off limits to saccharine TV.


Bookmark and Share


THE FIRST GRADER
National Geographic Entertainment

Reviewed for Arizona Reporter
By Harvey Karten

Grade: B+
Directed By: Justin Chadwick
Written By: Ann Peacock
Cast: Naomie Harris, Oliver Litondo, Tony Kgoroge, Shoki Mokgapa, Alfred Munyua, Vusi Kunene
Screened at: Review 2, NYC, 4/28/11
Opens: May 13, 2011

Yet another tale of how a great teacher can light a spark for people both inside and outside the classroom, "The First Grader" deals at least as much with the global inspiration activated by Kimani Ng'ang'a Maruge (Oliver Musila Litondo), a young-at-heart eight-four-year old who is listed in the Guinness Book of World Records as the oldest guy to start primary school with the kiddies. Litondo had a career as a news reader for his country's radio, then moved on to minor roles, and now issues forth with a strong performance as an old man who is determined to learn to read. Why wait until eighty-four to do this? This fellow is poverty-stricken like a great many people in that third-world country and is able to enroll in a public school only when his government declared in 2000 that everyone is entitled to a free education. Perhaps the lawyers should have looked into the law, because the devil is outside the details: no-one expected an octogenarian to exploit the ruling and sit side-by-side with people seventy-nine years younger than he.

This is an impressive movie not only for its message that education is fundamental but revives the sad history of British imperialism in East Africa, an incursion that led to a Mau Mau uprising against the foreign occupation. While the film does not go into details as much as showing how Maruge is hanged upside down and beaten because he would not renounce his oath to the Mau Mau-freedom fighters in Kenya but terrorists to the British-let it be known that this radical group began its rebellion in 1952 unleashing civil war, since as many men in the Kikuyu tribe fought with the British as were in the liberation army. (The Mau Mau did not have the success it dreamed of because the notion of nationalism did not hit home in a country that found loyalties to a tribe and not to a "nation").

In the story, based on true events including the fact that the 84-year-old student was invited to speak to the UN in New York when his activities reached out beyond his country-the local teacher, Jane Obinchu (British actress Naomie Harris) is not a fan of admitting the old man to her class until his persistence leads her to devote valuable classroom space in an economically pinched climate to the fellow. Many of the citizenry turned against the teacher, accusing her of spending too much time on Maruge and thereby depriving their own children of the education they need. She gets around the regulations ultimately by making him a "teaching assistant," and in fact the man does do some teaching on his own, telling stories to the energetic kids and leading them in tribal dance. One unusual facet is that when he shows up at an adult-education school to which he is shunted, he discovered that the "mature" adults are bigger discipline problems than any kids.

The flashback episodes of British action against the Mau Mau are not too frightening for a potentially young movie audience, though we see how the younger Maruge looks on as his wife and child are killed by the colonialists and he is beaten, later exposing his scarred back to the chairman of the country's education department in Nairobi.

The scenes with the children, even more than with teacher and the title character. are the soul of the film. These kids had not been auditioned in a national search but are actual pupils in godforsaken rural areas where they have to walk (or run) six miles each way to attend the school. (This running may be instrumental in Kenya's frequent victories in the annual New York marathons each November.)

Discount the sweetness of the film, which seems a negative for only critics, and you have a story that should appeal to general audiences the world over.

Rated PG-13. 103 minutes. © 2011 Harvey Karten Member: NY Film Critics Online.

Comment Using Facebook


<<< PREVIOUS ARTICLE NEXT ARTICLE >>>


Latest Movie Reviews
By Harvey Critic


HARVEY KARTEN, Ph.D.,
Member NYFCO
At the movie's conclusion, Lucy (Scarlett Johansson) states: "We've had life for a billion years. Now we know what to do with it." What does she think we should do with our lives? Presumably we should be able to stare at a gun and watch the bullets fall out harmlessly to the ground; look at a bunch of gangsters pointing AK-47s at us and have them drop their pieces and fly to the ceiling flaying impotently' conjure up dinosaurs and disappear just as they are about to gobble you up; and drive effortlessly down a one-way highway while watching cars pile up helplessly. In other words, while you may think that Lucy, who is steadily able to raise the capacity of her brain from the usual, human 10% to 100%, will be able to solve a Rubik Cube in 15 seconds, complete a New York Times Sunday crossword puzzle in indelible ink, or memorize 154 theorems in minutes without ever taking high-school geometry, Lucy's brain is completely different. Sure, she probably could learn to speak French with a Montréal accent if she should get the strange notion to do so, but writer-director Luc Besson has other plans for this brainiac. She has the powers of a superhero: she can exercise telekinesis by moving objects and people from one place to another by simply willing it, can take a quick look at the unspoiled U.S. when Native Americans ruled the land, and touch the forehead of a famous scientist to discover that his six-year-old daughter had died in an auto accident. What's more she can look at an X-ray of a person on an operating table, discern that he has advanced, incurable cancer, and shoot the poor fellow because "he could not possibly survive anyway."

Arizona Newsroom
Pushing the boundaries of classical ballet, Spain's emerging choreographic powerhouse Alejandro Cerrudo presents Off Screen, a dance inspired by film. It's sexy and modern with eccentric moves. Ib Andersen showcases the elegant and intricate Symphonie Classique with costumes by Tony Award-winning designer Martin Pakledinaz,and Indigo Rhapsody, an arresting and athletic ballet danced to Rachmaninoff's Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini.
The Arizona Game and Fish Department will host six public open houses where constituents may review and ask questions about the 2014 spring recommendations for turkey, javelina, buffalo and bear.


Finding Arizona Reporter


Sponsored Links
Arctic Cat Parts | Hyosung Parts | E-Ton Parts | CFMoto Parts